Wagner Ware Cast Iron Skillet (#8)

$40–$140
sits flat, no cracks, light pitting acceptable
24-month trend

What drives value

  • The value maker: 'Sidney -O-' marks and early stylized logos beat later plain marks
  • Flat beats pretty — a spinner (warped base) loses half its value on any logo
  • Machined-smooth interiors are the point; deep pitting in the cook surface hurts most
  • Odd sizes (#2, #12–14) and matching lids multiply the price

Recent sales

  • Sidney -O- #8, glass-smooth, flat (2026-06)$125
  • Wagner Ware #8, light pitting (2026-05)$55
  • #12 with heat ring, restored (2026-04)$190
  • Later 'Wagner' #8, slight spin (2026-02)$28

Shop similar on eBay →

Affiliate link — keeps the llama fed.

Ranges are editorial estimates from tracked sales; condition and region move prices.

Advertisement — 728×90